AI Visibility · Regional Scoreboard

BMW AI Visibility New York Metro

BMW dealers across New York

Regional report · 7 sub-markets
AI
VISIBILITY
Find Buy Service
Prepared August 2026Prepared by CarGenius
Overview

Executive summary

We measured how often AI assistants (ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overview) name each of the region's 16 BMW dealers when shoppers ask where to find, buy, and service - city by city. Here is who is winning AI visibility today, and where the gaps are.

BMW of Manhattan leads with 29% share of voice (of every time AI named a BMW dealer in the region) and is named in 81% of all answers. BMW of Brooklyn and BMW of Manhasset follow. The clearest gap is Park Avenue BMW, which AI names less often than its nearby shopper demand would suggest.

How to read this report. This draws on answers from ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overview. Dealers are never named in the questions, so every dealer is measured the same way. Cities are not counted equally: each city counts toward the regional score in proportion to how much BMW shopping happens there - measured by its monthly search demand - so a strong showing in high-demand markets like New York City and Queens moves a dealer's regional standing much more than the same showing in a small one. Every city's own results appear in the sub-market table below. The full method is at the end of this report.

The regional leaderboard

Who AI recommends most across the region. Share of voice: of every time AI named a BMW dealer in the region, how often it named this one. AI visibility: how often AI names the dealer at all. Named first: how often it is the very first dealer named.

  1. BMW of Manhattan - 29% share of voice, named in 81% of answers, named first 55% of the time; strongest sub-market: New York City.
  2. BMW of Brooklyn - 27% share of voice, named in 71% of answers, named first 30% of the time; strongest sub-market: Brooklyn.
  3. BMW of Manhasset - 14% share of voice, named in 37% of answers, named first 34% of the time; strongest sub-market: Hempstead.
  4. Ray Catena BMW of Westchester - 9% share of voice, named in 30% of answers, named first 6% of the time; strongest sub-market: Yonkers.
  5. BMW of Freeport - 8% share of voice, named in 23% of answers, named first 24% of the time; strongest sub-market: Hempstead.
  6. BMW of Mamaroneck - 4% share of voice, named in 13% of answers, named first 11% of the time; strongest sub-market: Yonkers.
  7. BMW of Bloomfield - 3% share of voice, named in 7% of answers, named first 60% of the time; strongest sub-market: Newark.
  8. Paul Miller BMW - 2% share of voice, named in 4% of answers, named first 7% of the time; strongest sub-market: Newark.
  9. Habberstad BMW - 1% share of voice, named in 4% of answers, named first 2% of the time; strongest sub-market: Hempstead.
  10. BMW of Ramsey - 1% share of voice, named in 3% of answers, named first 28% of the time; strongest sub-market: Jersey City.
  11. BMW of Tenafly - 1% share of voice, named in 2% of answers, named first 18% of the time; strongest sub-market: Jersey City.
  12. BMW of Morristown - 1% share of voice, named in 2% of answers, named first 23% of the time; strongest sub-market: Newark.
  13. Open Road BMW of Edison - 0% share of voice, named in 1% of answers, named first 4% of the time; strongest sub-market: Newark.
  14. BMW of Greenwich - 0% share of voice, named in 0% of answers, named first 3% of the time; strongest sub-market: Yonkers.
  15. Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore - 0% share of voice, named in 0% of answers, named first 0% of the time; strongest sub-market: Hempstead.
  16. Park Avenue BMW - 0% share of voice, named in 0% of answers, named first 0% of the time; strongest sub-market: Jersey City.

Who leads each sub-market, and where

  • New York City (population 8,804,190, 56,200 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Manhattan most.
  • Queens (population 2,316,841, 14,280 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Manhasset most.
  • Brooklyn (population 2,736,074, 12,640 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Brooklyn most.
  • Jersey City (population 264,290, 2,620 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Bloomfield most.
  • Newark (population 281,944, 2,150 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Bloomfield most.
  • Yonkers (population 201,116, 1,120 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Mamaroneck most.
  • Hempstead (population 55,547, 240 searches per month) - AI names BMW of Freeport most.

Bubble area is proportional to monthly search demand; the number keys each sub-market to the table. Small dots mark the tracked dealers' locations. Map © OpenStreetMap contributors.

What the region is searching for

  • BMW X5 - 24,500 searches per month
  • BMW X3 - 15,820 searches per month
  • BMW X7 - 12,740 searches per month
  • BMW X1 - 8,260 searches per month
  • BMW 3 Series - 5,590 searches per month
  • BMW 5 Series - 3,940 searches per month
  • BMW i4 - 3,750 searches per month
  • BMW iX - 3,590 searches per month
  • BMW i7 - 3,580 searches per month
  • BMW X2 - 3,000 searches per month

Top Sources

The websites AI cited most when answering shopper questions across the region, as a share of all citations:

  • dealerrater.com - 12.0% of citations
  • reddit.com - 9.3% of citations
  • yelp.com - 6.5% of citations
  • bmwofbrooklyn.com - 6.0% of citations
  • bmwnyc.com - 5.1% of citations
  • rallyebmw.com - 4.5% of citations
  • bmwofbloomfield.com - 3.7% of citations
  • cars.com - 3.4% of citations
  • parkavebmw.com - 3.3% of citations
  • carfax.com - 3.0% of citations
  • bmwoffreeport.com - 2.9% of citations
  • kbb.com - 2.9% of citations

Regional Insights

AI gives shoppers a short list of 2 to 3 dealers. AI answers with actual dealership names 98.8% of the time and names only 2 to 3 dealers per answer. A dealer not on that list loses the shopper to one that is.

The most Google reviews does not mean the most AI recommendations. Habberstad BMW has the region's most Google reviews (5,302) yet ranks 9th of 16 on this leaderboard, while BMW of Manhattan (2,501 reviews) ranks 1st.

AI's information comes from review sites and forums, not dealer websites. dealerrater.com alone is cited more than twice as often as any dealer website.

City "best dealership" lists feed AI's answers. Sites like Yelp publish a "Top 10 Best dealerships" page for each city, and AI cites them - Brooklyn's most of all. A dealer's rank on its own city's list affects what AI tells shoppers there.

New York City holds most of the demand - and no dealer has a firm lead. New York City and Queens together hold 79% of the region's shopping demand, yet in New York City, the busiest market, the most-recommended dealer (BMW of Manhattan) takes only 32% of AI's dealer mentions. AI names a different leading dealer in 6 of the 7 local areas.

Regional footprint

Who leads each sub-market, and where

The dealer AI names most in each sub-market. Each sub-market is measured at its anchor city - shown with its population - chosen to represent that part of the region; the anchors together span the metro's major population centers. On the map, each anchor's bubble is sized by its monthly shopper search demand, so larger circles are the markets with more search activity.

National footprint

The 25 metros, coast to coast

Each bubble is one of America's 25 biggest metro areas, sized by monthly shopper search demand in its anchor city and numbered by metro rank. The table that follows names the dealer AI recommends most in each.

Market demand

Where the nation shops

Monthly brand and model searches in each metro's anchor city - the demand AI answers compete for. Search demand weights and sizes the markets in this report; it is not a sales figure.

Market demand

What the region is searching for

How many shoppers near the region search for each model every month. This is the demand AI answers compete for, and it sets how much each city counts toward the scores. Search demand weights the cities in this report; it is not a sales figure.

Metro leaderboard

The National 25 - who AI recommends, metro by metro

The dealer AI assistants recommend most in each of the nation's 25 biggest metros, measured with identical non-branded Find / Buy / Service questions in each metro's anchor city.

How to read this. Share of voice: of every time AI named a dealer in this metro, how often it named this one. AI visibility: how often AI names the dealer at all. Named first: how often it is the very first dealer named - kept separate from visibility, as always. Bars are scaled to a 50% share.

Regional leaderboard

The regional leaderboard

Who AI recommends most across the region. Share of voice is the headline: out of every time AI named a dealer, how often it named this one. AI visibility is how often AI names the dealer at all, and named first is how often it is the very first dealer named - a dealer can be named often yet rarely first, so we keep these separate. Cities with more shopper demand count for more.

#DealerStrongest sub-marketAI visibilityShare of voiceNamed first
1BMW of ManhattanNew York City81%
29%
55%
2BMW of BrooklynBrooklyn71%
27%
30%
3BMW of ManhassetHempstead37%
14%
34%
4Ray Catena BMW of WestchesterYonkers30%
9%
6%
5BMW of FreeportHempstead23%
8%
24%
6BMW of MamaroneckYonkers13%
4%
11%
7BMW of BloomfieldNewark7%
3%
60%
8Paul Miller BMWNewark4%
2%
7%
9Habberstad BMWHempstead4%
1%
2%
10BMW of RamseyJersey City3%
1%
28%
11BMW of TenaflyJersey City2%
1%
18%
12BMW of MorristownNewark2%
1%
23%
13Open Road BMW of EdisonNewark1%
0%
4%
14BMW of GreenwichYonkers0%
0%
3%
15Habberstad BMW of Bay ShoreHempstead0%
0%
0%
16Park Avenue BMWJersey City0%
0%
0%
Winning patterns

The winners are not who you'd expect

The two things dealers invest in as reputation - store size and Google rating - do not separate the AI leaders from the field. Most metros are led by a store that is not the biggest in its market, winning under its own local name.

Where AI's winners rank by store size. Every metro's dealers, ranked by Google review count; the groups below show where each metro's AI leader falls in that size order.

Dealer scorecard

Dealer ranking scorecard

Read each grade cell as two numbers: a bold 0-100 grade, and in grey the share of voice it comes from. The grade is relative - the region's strongest dealer scores 100 and every other dealer is measured against it. Find, Buy and Service are graded on their own and count equally toward the Weighted overall. "Weighted" means busier cities count for more: each city's result is scaled by its monthly search demand before the cities are combined, so how a dealer does where the shoppers are matters most.

AI sources

Top Sources

The websites AI cited most when answering shopper questions across the region - each shown as its share of all the citations AI made. Getting listed and well-reviewed on the sources that rank highest here is how a dealer gets into AI answers.

AI sources

What AI reads, nationally

Store size and ratings do not decide who AI recommends. The clearest national pattern is what AI reads: the same few sources appear in metro after metro. Each website is shown as its share of all the citations AI made across the 25 measured metros. Getting listed and well-reviewed on the sources that rank highest here is how a dealer gets into AI answers.

Market opportunity

Most metros are still up for grabs

The small number next to each metro is the leader's share of voice divided by the runner-up's - 1.0x means the leader and runner-up are tied.

Contested - the runner-up is within striking distance Held - the leader is comfortably ahead Bubble size = market size (monthly searches)

Leader's share of voice

Of every time AI named a dealer in that metro, the percentage that went to the metro's #1 dealer.

Runner-up's share of voice

The same measure for the #2 dealer. The closer the two shares, the closer the race; a leader can never sit below the dashed line, only above it.

Share of voice = a dealer's AI mentions ÷ all dealers' AI mentions in its metro
Striking distance = the runner-up holds at least the leader's share ÷ 1.2
Market opportunity

Share of Voice vs Share of Demand

This chart plots each dealer's Share of Voice (up) against its Share of Demand (across). The dashed line is break-even, where the two are equal. Below it, a dealer's Share of Demand is larger than its Share of Voice - the clearest gaps to close. Bubbles are sized by Google review count.

At or above its opportunity Below its opportunity (a gap) Bubble size = Google review count

Share of Voice

When AI assistants recommend dealers in this region, the percentage of those recommendations that go to this dealer.

Share of Demand

This dealer's slice of the region's shoppers, based on distance: each town's shoppers count toward the stores nearest them, and busier towns count for more.

Share of voice = a dealer's AI mentions ÷ all dealers' AI mentions
Share of demand = a dealer's nearby demand ÷ all dealers' nearby demand
Regional insights

Regional Insights

These patterns stand out when the region's answers are read together. Each one is computed from the measured runs behind this report.

National insights

National insights

Beyond the headline story, these patterns stand out when all the metros are read together. Each one is computed from the measured runs - per-metro results are directional, but these cross-metro patterns rest on the full national sample.

Recommended actions

What To Do

The patterns in this report are national, but the actions they point to are local - and none of them requires being the biggest store in the market. Five places to start, each grounded in what this measurement found.

Methodology

Methodology

We asked non-dealer branded questions - for example "best BMW dealer near [city]", "BMW X5 inventory near [city]", and "where to service a BMW near [city]" - against ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overview, city by city, and recorded which dealers each answer named and in what order. Dealers are never named in the questions, so every dealer in the region is measured the same way and the leaderboard reflects who AI brings up on its own. Search demand comes from Google search volume for in-market shopping terms by model and city; it weights each city and is not a sales figure. Every confirmed BMW dealership in the region's measured footprint is tracked and scored - 16 dealers in this report.

Position is reported only as "named first". How often AI names a dealer and how early it names them are separate measurements, and this report keeps them separate. Because the weighting follows measured demand, New York City and Queens together carry about 79% of the regional score; every city's own results are shown in the sub-market table. Search demand: Google search volume. AI visibility: live queries to ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overview. Dealer ratings: Google Business Profile and Yelp.

Next step · For your dealership

Custom Dealer Reports

This regional report shows how AI sees the whole market. A Custom Dealer Report goes deeper on one dealership: yours.

This national report shows how AI sees dealers across America's biggest metros. A Custom Dealer Report goes deeper on one dealership: yours.

Every month, CarGenius runs the questions your buyers ask across the major AI engines and reports how often AI names you versus each competitor, scores your Find, Buy, and Service visibility, verifies your marketplace presence, and ranks what to fix by effort and impact.

Get a Custom Report
Custom Dealer Report · sample data

Most-mentioned dealers in your market

How often AI names each dealer across this month's shopping prompts
Your Dealership
54%
Competitor A
41%
Competitor B
33%
Competitor C
27%
FIND
72/100
BUY
41/100
SERVICE
58/100
About CarGenius

About CarGenius

CarGenius builds AI commerce infrastructure for car dealerships - so a dealership can be found, understood, and chosen when car shoppers ask AI.

Infrastructure

MCP Server

Connects your DMS, inventory, and pricing directly to AI agents in real time.

AI Search

On-Site AI

Conversational search for your own website, built for how car buyers shop.

AI Services

Expert Support

White-glove implementation and AEO reporting, like this report.

BMW
New York
[{"label":"Leads the region","name":"BMW of Manhattan","value":"29%","value_label":" share of voice","sub":"Named in 81% of answers"},{"label":"2nd","name":"BMW of Brooklyn","value":"27%","value_label":" share of voice","sub":"Named in 71% of answers"},{"label":"3rd","name":"BMW of Manhasset","value":"14%","value_label":" share of voice","sub":"Named in 37% of answers"}]
{"submarkets":[{"n":1,"name":"New York City","lat":40.71427,"lng":-74.00597,"demand":56200,"leader":"BMW of Manhattan"},{"n":2,"name":"Queens","lat":40.68149,"lng":-73.83652,"demand":14280,"leader":"BMW of Manhasset"},{"n":3,"name":"Brooklyn","lat":40.6501,"lng":-73.94958,"demand":12640,"leader":"BMW of Brooklyn"},{"n":4,"name":"Jersey City","lat":40.72816,"lng":-74.07764,"demand":2620,"leader":"BMW of Bloomfield"},{"n":5,"name":"Newark","lat":40.73566,"lng":-74.17237,"demand":2150,"leader":"BMW of Bloomfield"},{"n":6,"name":"Yonkers","lat":40.9304,"lng":-73.89789,"demand":1120,"leader":"BMW of Mamaroneck"},{"n":7,"name":"Hempstead","lat":40.70621,"lng":-73.61874,"demand":240,"leader":"BMW of Freeport"}],"dealers":[{"name":"Habberstad BMW","lat":40.8361078,"lng":-73.3749634},{"name":"BMW of Freeport","lat":40.655595999999996,"lng":-73.59477009999999},{"name":"BMW of Ramsey","lat":41.065286,"lng":-74.131979},{"name":"Paul Miller BMW","lat":40.9356614,"lng":-74.2707887},{"name":"BMW of Bloomfield","lat":40.7890386,"lng":-74.194728},{"name":"Open Road BMW of Edison","lat":40.5092991,"lng":-74.386944},{"name":"Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore","lat":40.726888599999995,"lng":-73.2833498},{"name":"BMW of Morristown","lat":40.8031041,"lng":-74.4640156},{"name":"BMW of Brooklyn","lat":40.6170008,"lng":-74.0310394},{"name":"Ray Catena BMW of Westchester","lat":41.0441151,"lng":-73.80338789999999},{"name":"BMW of Manhattan","lat":40.770578,"lng":-73.9908368},{"name":"BMW of Tenafly","lat":40.9342233,"lng":-73.957572},{"name":"BMW of Greenwich","lat":41.0231978,"lng":-73.6385152},{"name":"BMW of Mamaroneck","lat":40.9468022,"lng":-73.73514399999999},{"name":"BMW of Manhasset","lat":40.792699999999996,"lng":-73.69887609999999},{"name":"Park Avenue BMW","lat":40.905864099999995,"lng":-74.0709523}]}
[{"n":1,"name":"New York City","population":8804190,"searches":56200,"leader":"BMW of Manhattan"},{"n":2,"name":"Queens","population":2316841,"searches":14280,"leader":"BMW of Manhasset"},{"n":3,"name":"Brooklyn","population":2736074,"searches":12640,"leader":"BMW of Brooklyn"},{"n":4,"name":"Jersey City","population":264290,"searches":2620,"leader":"BMW of Bloomfield"},{"n":5,"name":"Newark","population":281944,"searches":2150,"leader":"BMW of Bloomfield"},{"n":6,"name":"Yonkers","population":201116,"searches":1120,"leader":"BMW of Mamaroneck"},{"n":7,"name":"Hempstead","population":55547,"searches":240,"leader":"BMW of Freeport"}]
[{"model":"BMW X5","searches":24500},{"model":"BMW X3","searches":15820},{"model":"BMW X7","searches":12740},{"model":"BMW X1","searches":8260},{"model":"BMW 3 Series","searches":5590},{"model":"BMW 5 Series","searches":3940},{"model":"BMW i4","searches":3750},{"model":"BMW iX","searches":3590},{"model":"BMW i7","searches":3580},{"model":"BMW X2","searches":3000}]
[{"rank":1,"dealer":"BMW of Manhattan","strongest":"New York City","visibility":0.811,"sov":0.2931,"first_rate":0.5546},{"rank":2,"dealer":"BMW of Brooklyn","strongest":"Brooklyn","visibility":0.7091,"sov":0.2695,"first_rate":0.2983},{"rank":3,"dealer":"BMW of Manhasset","strongest":"Hempstead","visibility":0.3684,"sov":0.1381,"first_rate":0.3418},{"rank":4,"dealer":"Ray Catena BMW of Westchester","strongest":"Yonkers","visibility":0.3004,"sov":0.0949,"first_rate":0.0596},{"rank":5,"dealer":"BMW of Freeport","strongest":"Hempstead","visibility":0.2273,"sov":0.0813,"first_rate":0.2389},{"rank":6,"dealer":"BMW of Mamaroneck","strongest":"Yonkers","visibility":0.1272,"sov":0.0399,"first_rate":0.1137},{"rank":7,"dealer":"BMW of Bloomfield","strongest":"Newark","visibility":0.0714,"sov":0.0262,"first_rate":0.6037},{"rank":8,"dealer":"Paul Miller BMW","strongest":"Newark","visibility":0.0409,"sov":0.0171,"first_rate":0.0681},{"rank":9,"dealer":"Habberstad BMW","strongest":"Hempstead","visibility":0.0358,"sov":0.0114,"first_rate":0.0222},{"rank":10,"dealer":"BMW of Ramsey","strongest":"Jersey City","visibility":0.0314,"sov":0.0114,"first_rate":0.2802},{"rank":11,"dealer":"BMW of Tenafly","strongest":"Jersey City","visibility":0.0172,"sov":0.0063,"first_rate":0.18},{"rank":12,"dealer":"BMW of Morristown","strongest":"Newark","visibility":0.0151,"sov":0.0058,"first_rate":0.2332},{"rank":13,"dealer":"Open Road BMW of Edison","strongest":"Newark","visibility":0.0065,"sov":0.0023,"first_rate":0.0376},{"rank":14,"dealer":"BMW of Greenwich","strongest":"Yonkers","visibility":0.0031,"sov":0.0013,"first_rate":0.0333},{"rank":15,"dealer":"Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore","strongest":"Hempstead","visibility":0.0029,"sov":0.0012,"first_rate":0.0},{"rank":16,"dealer":"Park Avenue BMW","strongest":"Jersey City","visibility":0.0005,"sov":0.0003,"first_rate":0.0}]
[{"rank":1,"dealer":"BMW of Manhattan","overall":{"grade":100,"share":0.2931},"find":{"grade":100,"share":0.2729},"buy":{"grade":100,"share":0.2627},"service":{"grade":100,"share":0.3438},"sentiment":58,"google":{"rating":4.4,"reviews":2501},"yelp":{"rating":2.6,"reviews":354}},{"rank":2,"dealer":"BMW of Brooklyn","overall":{"grade":92,"share":0.2695},"find":{"grade":98,"share":0.268},"buy":{"grade":78,"share":0.205},"service":{"grade":98,"share":0.3355},"sentiment":58,"google":{"rating":4.8,"reviews":2716},"yelp":{"rating":2.7,"reviews":224}},{"rank":3,"dealer":"BMW of Manhasset","overall":{"grade":47,"share":0.1381},"find":{"grade":33,"share":0.0904},"buy":{"grade":62,"share":0.1639},"service":{"grade":47,"share":0.16},"sentiment":61,"google":{"rating":4.8,"reviews":2696},"yelp":{"rating":2.4,"reviews":218}},{"rank":4,"dealer":"Ray Catena BMW of Westchester","overall":{"grade":32,"share":0.0949},"find":{"grade":57,"share":0.1564},"buy":{"grade":41,"share":0.107},"service":{"grade":6,"share":0.0212},"sentiment":62,"google":{"rating":4.8,"reviews":2536},"yelp":{"rating":3.0,"reviews":118}},{"rank":5,"dealer":"BMW of Freeport","overall":{"grade":28,"share":0.0813},"find":{"grade":35,"share":0.096},"buy":{"grade":35,"share":0.0916},"service":{"grade":16,"share":0.0564},"sentiment":63,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":4684},"yelp":{"rating":3.8,"reviews":328}},{"rank":6,"dealer":"BMW of Mamaroneck","overall":{"grade":14,"share":0.0399},"find":{"grade":11,"share":0.029},"buy":{"grade":32,"share":0.0845},"service":{"grade":2,"share":0.0061},"sentiment":58,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":809},"yelp":{"rating":2.8,"reviews":73}},{"rank":7,"dealer":"BMW of Bloomfield","overall":{"grade":9,"share":0.0262},"find":{"grade":6,"share":0.0172},"buy":{"grade":14,"share":0.0367},"service":{"grade":7,"share":0.0246},"sentiment":60,"google":{"rating":4.6,"reviews":4185},"yelp":{"rating":2.5,"reviews":242}},{"rank":8,"dealer":"Paul Miller BMW","overall":{"grade":6,"share":0.0171},"find":{"grade":5,"share":0.0139},"buy":{"grade":4,"share":0.0095},"service":{"grade":8,"share":0.028},"sentiment":62,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":4328},"yelp":{"rating":2.7,"reviews":159}},{"rank":9,"dealer":"Habberstad BMW","overall":{"grade":4,"share":0.0114},"find":{"grade":12,"share":0.0336},"buy":{"grade":0,"share":0.0005},"service":{"grade":0,"share":0.0001},"sentiment":57,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":5302},"yelp":{"rating":2.9,"reviews":181}},{"rank":10,"dealer":"BMW of Ramsey","overall":{"grade":4,"share":0.0114},"find":{"grade":2,"share":0.0044},"buy":{"grade":6,"share":0.0161},"service":{"grade":4,"share":0.0137},"sentiment":60,"google":{"rating":4.6,"reviews":4391},"yelp":{"rating":3.1,"reviews":291}},{"rank":11,"dealer":"BMW of Tenafly","overall":{"grade":2,"share":0.0063},"find":{"grade":3,"share":0.009},"buy":{"grade":3,"share":0.0068},"service":{"grade":1,"share":0.003},"sentiment":61,"google":{"rating":4.6,"reviews":2083},"yelp":{"rating":3.1,"reviews":246}},{"rank":12,"dealer":"BMW of Morristown","overall":{"grade":2,"share":0.0058},"find":{"grade":3,"share":0.0071},"buy":{"grade":3,"share":0.0077},"service":{"grade":1,"share":0.0027},"sentiment":58,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":2765},"yelp":{"rating":2.8,"reviews":273}},{"rank":13,"dealer":"Open Road BMW of Edison","overall":{"grade":1,"share":0.0023},"find":{"grade":1,"share":0.0016},"buy":{"grade":2,"share":0.0052},"service":{"grade":0,"share":0.0},"sentiment":59,"google":{"rating":4.5,"reviews":4144},"yelp":{"rating":2.7,"reviews":276}},{"rank":14,"dealer":"BMW of Greenwich","overall":{"grade":0,"share":0.0013},"find":{"grade":0,"share":0.0006},"buy":{"grade":1,"share":0.0017},"service":{"grade":0,"share":0.0015},"sentiment":55,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":986},"yelp":{"rating":2.7,"reviews":65}},{"rank":15,"dealer":"Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore","overall":{"grade":0,"share":0.0012},"find":{"grade":0,"share":0.0},"buy":{"grade":0,"share":0.0003},"service":{"grade":1,"share":0.0034},"sentiment":55,"google":{"rating":4.7,"reviews":3611},"yelp":{"rating":2.9,"reviews":102}},{"rank":16,"dealer":"Park Avenue BMW","overall":{"grade":0,"share":0.0003},"find":{"grade":0,"share":0.0},"buy":{"grade":0,"share":0.0008},"service":{"grade":0,"share":0.0},"sentiment":73,"google":{"rating":4.3,"reviews":997},"yelp":{"rating":2.7,"reviews":53}}]
[{"domain":"dealerrater.com","cls":"UGC","share":0.12},{"domain":"reddit.com","cls":"UGC","share":0.0926},{"domain":"yelp.com","cls":"UGC","share":0.0646},{"domain":"bmwofbrooklyn.com","cls":"Other","share":0.06},{"domain":"bmwnyc.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0514},{"domain":"rallyebmw.com","cls":"Other","share":0.0446},{"domain":"bmwofbloomfield.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0366},{"domain":"cars.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0343},{"domain":"parkavebmw.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0331},{"domain":"carfax.com","cls":"Other","share":0.0303},{"domain":"bmwoffreeport.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0291},{"domain":"kbb.com","cls":"Corporate","share":0.0291}]
[{"dealer":"BMW of Manhattan","label":"Manhattan","sov":0.2931,"demand_share":0.2718,"reviews":2501},{"dealer":"BMW of Brooklyn","label":"Brooklyn","sov":0.2695,"demand_share":0.1551,"reviews":2716},{"dealer":"BMW of Manhasset","label":"Manhasset","sov":0.1381,"demand_share":0.0629,"reviews":2696},{"dealer":"Ray Catena BMW of Westchester","label":"Ray Catena Westchester","sov":0.0949,"demand_share":0.03,"reviews":2536},{"dealer":"BMW of Freeport","label":"Freeport","sov":0.0813,"demand_share":0.0486,"reviews":4684},{"dealer":"BMW of Mamaroneck","label":"Mamaroneck","sov":0.0399,"demand_share":0.0393,"reviews":809},{"dealer":"BMW of Bloomfield","label":"Bloomfield","sov":0.0262,"demand_share":0.0723,"reviews":4185},{"dealer":"Paul Miller BMW","label":"Paul Miller","sov":0.0171,"demand_share":0.0307,"reviews":4328},{"dealer":"Habberstad BMW","label":"Habberstad","sov":0.0114,"demand_share":0.0273,"reviews":5302},{"dealer":"BMW of Ramsey","label":"Ramsey","sov":0.0114,"demand_share":0.0254,"reviews":4391},{"dealer":"BMW of Tenafly","label":"Tenafly","sov":0.0063,"demand_share":0.0584,"reviews":2083},{"dealer":"BMW of Morristown","label":"Morristown","sov":0.0058,"demand_share":0.0259,"reviews":2765},{"dealer":"Open Road BMW of Edison","label":"Open Road Edison","sov":0.0023,"demand_share":0.0421,"reviews":4144},{"dealer":"BMW of Greenwich","label":"Greenwich","sov":0.0013,"demand_share":0.0268,"reviews":986},{"dealer":"Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore","label":"Habberstad Bay Shore","sov":0.0012,"demand_share":0.0268,"reviews":3611},{"dealer":"Park Avenue BMW","label":"Park Avenue","sov":0.0003,"demand_share":0.0567,"reviews":997}]
[{"title":"AI gives shoppers a short list of 2 to 3 dealers","html":"AI answers with actual dealership names 98.8% of the time and names only 2 to 3 dealers per answer. A dealer not on that list loses the shopper to one that is."},{"title":"The most Google reviews does not mean the most AI recommendations","html":"Habberstad BMW has the region's most Google reviews (5,302) yet ranks 9th of 16 on this leaderboard, while BMW of Manhattan (2,501 reviews) ranks 1st."},{"title":"AI's information comes from review sites and forums, not dealer websites","html":"dealerrater.com alone is cited more than twice as often as any dealer website."},{"title":"City \"best dealership\" lists feed AI's answers","html":"Sites like Yelp publish a \"Top 10 Best dealerships\" page for each city, and AI cites them - Brooklyn's most of all. A dealer's rank on its own city's list affects what AI tells shoppers there."},{"title":"New York City holds most of the demand - and no dealer has a firm lead","html":"New York City and Queens together hold 79% of the region's shopping demand, yet in New York City, the busiest market, the most-recommended dealer (BMW of Manhattan) takes only 32% of AI's dealer mentions. AI names a different leading dealer in 6 of the 7 local areas."}]
Bubble area is proportional to monthly search demand; the number keys each sub-market to the table. Small dots mark the tracked dealers' locations. Map © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Regional